Every flavor Erins Sugar Shop bakes.
All the flavors and fillings on the menu, gathered in one place. Don’t see what you’re after? Request a quote and ask.
Ready to order?
Erins Sugar Shop usually replies in 1–2 days with a custom quote tailored to your order.
Common questions, answered.
Does Erins Sugar Shop take custom orders?
Yes. Erins Sugar Shop takes custom order requests through their Cakery page. Tap "Request a quote", describe what you need, and they will reply with a price, usually within 1 to 2 days.
What does Erins Sugar Shop sell?
Erins Sugar Shop's menu includes cookies. The full menu on this page lists flavors, fillings, and starting prices.
Where is Erins Sugar Shop located?
Erins Sugar Shop is based in Riverview, FL. Ask about pickup and delivery options when you request a quote.
How do I order from Erins Sugar Shop?
Browse the menu on this page, then tap "Request a quote". You can start from a listed item or describe a fully custom idea. Popular dates can fill up, so it helps to reach out early.


